Let's Talk about 'Theory X','Theory Y' & 'Theory Z' too...!!
The term Theory symbolizes some boring "Gyaan". Since childhood we have faced a lot of them in subjects like Maths, Physics and so on, and surely when we think of management, we definitely want to spare ourselves from this term "Theory". But herein when we talk about Human Resources, Leadership, Handling People, peer-2-peer relations, in all we can say Operational Behavior of any organisation, two theories flash some light on few of the major aspects of Employee behavior & Management perspective. They are togetherly famous as THEORY-X & THEORY-Y.
Let's see few of simple questions :
1. Actually what is all this ?
> a) Essentially Theory X and Theory Y describe two opposing views of people at work that will influence management style.
b) Managers can be said to follow either view of their workforce.
c) Theory X is often said to describe a traditional view of direction and control.
d) Theory Y implies a more self directed workforce that takes an interest in the goals of their organisation and integrates some of their own goals into these.
> (some history)..
Douglas McGregor (1906-1964) was Professor of Management at the MIT College Sloan School of Management, and President of Antioch College. He also taught at the Indian Institute of Management, Calcutta. Theory X and Theory Y are theories McGregor created, and developed in the 1960's, and published in his book 'The Human Side of Enterprise'. He is often credited for the term 'human resources', and studied and quoted widely in the areas of organizational development, organizational culture, leadership and HR.
3. What is Theory X ?
> In this theory, management makes the following assumptions about employees:
a)That they are inherently lazy, & will avoid work if they can.
b)That they show little or no ambition.
c)That they avoid responsibility wherever they can.
d)That they lack creativity in solving organizational problems.
e)That money and the security it brings is the only motivator to work.
If an organization makes these assumptions, the management style reflects these beliefs, and as a result, relies on close supervision, control, coercion and threat of punishment.
(eg. losing their job) to achieve it's goals.
4. What is Theory Y ?
> In this theory, management believes that, given the right conditions:
a)Work is as natural as play and rest
b)Most people do want to do well at work
c)The satisfaction of doing a good job is a strong motivator
d)Employees may be ambitious and self-motivated
The underlying belief here is that people have potential, and are capable of using their creativity and ingenuity to solve organizational problems. Theory Y is generally held as a positive set of beliefs about workers. With Theory Y, the role of managers is to develop the potential of employees, and by doing so, to meet organizational goals.
5. Theory X managers v/s Theory Y Managers:
> Figures speak better than words, so I won't make you boredom by my writing. Please find these excellent comparison I found on the jargon of internet. (Credits : Google)
6. Something I came across, "Theory Z"
> (I guess this is out of portion, so we can skip this part. :-P)
Theory Z deals with the way in which workers are perceived by managers, as well as how managers are perceived by workers; is created and developed by William Ouchi. Theory Z assumes that workers tend to want to build co-operative and intimate working relationships with those that they work for and with, as well as the people that work for them.
These types of workers have a very well developed sense of order, discipline, moral obligation to work hard, and a sense of cohesion with their fellow workers. Finally, Theory Z workers, it is assumed, can be trusted to do their jobs to their utmost ability, so long as management can be trusted to support them and look out for their well being.
6. So Whats the Conclusion ?
> Again some Figures :
(I think that explains everything of it.)
Special Thanks to Prof. Prasad T. (Mandi Sir) for few of his enlightening sessions @ NITIE.
- Prathamesh V Avale (IM21-1402116)











No comments:
Post a Comment